Its your choice to believe what you want to believe and you are the only one that has to be happy with it. Please keep this in mind
1 - compare the S at the end of Collins. All his secretarial go to the right, all his known authentic the S will come back towards the left
2 - Phil Collins is retired and lives in Switzerland, rarely returning to England. All the successes are through the London office with a very fast turnaround time. This alone makes it impossible for it to be real as he was not in the Country.
Again, believe what you want and congratulations on your success but if you are searching for the truth, there is overwhelming evidence that it is secretarial.

I am not expert, However I want to argue with you. I think that my autograph is authentic {thumb2} . I have DVD disk with PP autograph of Phil Collins. And I have compared both signatures. The Handwriting alike and some elements( I have outline) similar too. What do you say? Or dvd signed by secretarial too? (Sorry for my english)

I am 99.9 percent sure they are secretarial, compare yours to here
http://www.autographworld.com/sigs/comp ... ln=Collins

Also, as stated above, Phil Collins lives in Switzerland and spends almost all his time there. There is no info on the web stating he was in England when yours were signed. All the through the mail success that I have seen look like yours and are different from in person. Enjoy your success for what they most likely are

Im pretty sure all Phil's autos TT are authentic becasue when I sent for a second request I was turned down becasue they say he is cutting down on his paperwork which makes me think they would say that if they were secs.

Thank you for your reply . I receive it 15 dec 2008 from London.I thought it is authentic...

Very small picture so I'll go on the stamps - if it came from London recently (during the past year or so), it is a secretarial signature since Mr. Collins lives in Switzerland.

What do you think?