yeah I'm afraid both are fake.

sorry, but imo they are both fake. Neither seems quite right, but The Brady is too far away to accurately tell, but if you were selling these you would want to show the details if they were authentic to get more bids. Those who sell fakes tend to show their product poorly to hide the inaccuracies. They should be photographed individually, not from a distance and at at an angle that distorts the details.

I won an auction on ebay for Tom Brady and Peyton Manning autographs together, and I compared them to a couple pictures before the auction ended. To me they look authentic, but what do you think?