Ok an update, i contacted the person i bought these from and asked if they had any proof (other than COA as i consider these pretty worthless) of these being signed, she sent me a pic of R.Pat signing these - however i agree that the rest look on closer inspection pretty poor and im inclined to believe that the seller has probably filled them in so make it look more impressive.

Thanks for all the comments, dissapointed but i purposefully didn't pay much for them jsut incase and i have sent requests off myself so hopefully i will get my own authentics

Fake. Elaborating on what someone said above: if this was an earlier Rob sig, or perhaps 'I have time to sit down and write neatly' then I'd be more inclined to consider it real. However, it's on an Eclipse poster, and scrawled. The more Rob sigs, the more often he sigs just his initial.

That is just horrible...

Those are brutal.
Funny enough, the closest looking one to real there is the Rob on the 2nd photo... I still think its fake just because all the others are & its in the same pen though.

If that squiggle is Jackson Rathbone's signature, I think its fake.

Nikki Reed and Ashley Greene look a little off to me...

Pattinson looks ok. Like charliestcloud said Lutz looks odd to me too. Greene doesn't look real either. Rathbone and Facinelli looks fake. They are all done with the same pen so if one isn't real, then none of them are. But that's just my option. Where did you get it?

any other ideas?

charliestcloud wrote:Some of them look real like Rob's but Kellan's is looking a little odd to me....

Robs is the main reason that i bought them and just cause they are quite nice group autos, i did try and do alot of comparisons before i bought them but robs auto seems to change even in in person autos but it did look quite real to me. If some of the others aren't real im not overly unhappy, if robs is!

Some of them look real like Rob's but Kellan's is looking a little odd to me....