I think Jeter has an exclusive contract through Steiner. I think that restricts him from signing. Kinda like Tiger Woods with Upper Deck. I think you will find that is the case with many of the bigger stars. Your best bet is in person or buying via dealer like other posters have said.

I know there have been successes from Brett Gardner and Nick Swisher...seen on another site. Nick Swisher is a super nice, generous guy (came from my hometown in WV) so I think he'd be more than willing.

yeah i got an amazing mariano rivera on an allen and ginter! since u collect yankee autographss does anyone know if there are any current/former players that sign? i really want current players!!

Your best bet is to try and get one through a certified dealer...going to cost you though. Either that, or find one on ebay thats been certified by PSA/DNA...will end up being cheaper that way. But he doesn't sign anything TTM. Same goes for A-Rod, Ryan Howard, Prince Fielder, etc.

Write Mariano Riviera..seen some successes from him.

Honestly? No. I've been collecting autographs from the Yankees TTM for many, many years and I would never bother with sending Jeter anything. That being said, there are loads of NY Yankees from past and present that sign TTM.

Dont think Jeter signs through the mail. I would try him in about 20 years after he retires haha. Ill be writing then!

I mailed a picture, SAA to the address listed on Fanmail.biz on March 11, 2010, which no luck yet. I am hopeful though! Anybody think I will have any luck, ever?