Ashley replies to almost EVERY one she gets, and the same for Lucy. Shay and Troian (Of course MY favorite) are the hardest to get. Troian does reply, she just takes longest. Shay is fairly easy, but there are only about 3 successes from her on this site. I think the addresses for Shay are incorrect. I tried (literally, just yesterday) Shay, Lucy, and Troian. I sent them all to the Via Venue address. I've heard success from Shay at that one. Shay is my favorite. Tomorrow i'm sending to Ashley, but i'm contemplating on which one I should send to. I've heard success on Ashley with BOTH addresses.

DON'T send to the "fan mail" address. That address is for people who want to send letters ONLY, and NOT recieve anything back. That is the biggest mistake people are making.

GOOD LUCK (wish me luck, too!)

I've sent mine to Lucy but still no reply back yet ):
I think the only one that doesn't sign is Trojan but Ashley is pretty good about fan mail

I have seen a lot of successes of Ashley Benson and one of Lucy Hale....
i think i saw a success of Shay Mitchell but i not sure

Has anyone sent any of them? I don't want to if it will be a waste, because they might get a lot!