I'm thinking of maybe trying to resend in about a year or so. I originally sent out the index card as somewhat of a feeler to see if the address was correct and if he would sign at all since feedback on him seems to be 50/50.

Hi kml63116

Thank you for your feedback and Sorry for your RTS

Would you have a scan of the RTS envelope you received please?
If so, you are in the run for the $10 gift certificate.

Joe Sakic on Fanmail.biz | Previous Feedback(s) Received

Fanmail

Well truthfully if he signed a index card for you in September already he probably thought you were being greedy and 1 autograph was enough because lets be honest if he signed your index card in September of this year you should have considered yourself lucky and not sent more to him like hes some autograph signing monkey lol I don't think it has anything to do with the puck I think he just figured you were being greedy at this point and I would have to agree...

did you send it c/o the Avalanche?

Sent a puck, pen, sase, and lor to address in database on 10/25/13. Received back today RTS written on it. Also had a sticker from post office marked refused. Kind of disappointed because I had sent an index card back in 9/13 and received it back in about 7 days. Maybe he only signs flats and could tell right away it was a puck. At least he sent it back instead of just trashing it because it was a Stanley cup champion puck that I had bought on eBay.