That's cool. IMO sending donations is a good way of increasing your chances of getting an autograph, but you can (and I have!) get burned. In this case, it's rude to keep his $10 but mail everything else back. He was exchanging $10 for an autograph... If $10 isn't enough, just mail it back with everything else. It's going to a good cause, but still, it seems rude. Just my 2-cents!

i got him 2 times from this address sending $20 tho

I would not chance sending $20. Since they sent his items back, they should have included his $10 with a note stating $20+ gets you an autograph.

Hi sportsautographs1

Thank you for your feedback

Peyton Manning on Fanmail.biz | Previous Feedback(s) Received

Fanmail

you have to send $20 or more !!!

SENT $10 TO PEYBACK FOUNDATION WITH A PHOTO, SASE, AND NICE LETTER.

KEPT $ AND SENT PHOTOS BACK UNSIGNED.