I tried to get Cook's auto last year but didn't get a reply. Archie was extremely great with his fans and sent our loads of replies. Brooke too but most of the contestants were pretty lame with fanmail as far as I know. This year I sent out to all except for Scott (obvious reasons) and got a reply from Danny today. There's another Danny success on the forum plus Matt and Kris {??}
I'm checking the threads for Idol successes every day (and my mailbox, of course ;) )

from the past years, most wait to sign after their voted off, their pretty busy while their still competing. both David Cook and David Archeleta signed last year so I dont really see a reason this years group wouldnt sign.

[quote="aamir"]The only Idol success so far has been from Matt Giraud.
Personally, I do not think Adam or Allison will reply, but you can always try.
I am not trying to discourage you, I just think they will not reply.
Matt Giraud must be getting loads of mail. I'm glad he replied to someone's![/quote]

Why don't you think so?

The only Idol success so far has been from Matt Giraud.
Personally, I do not think Adam or Allison will reply, but you can always try.
I am not trying to discourage you, I just think they will not reply.
Matt Giraud must be getting loads of mail. I'm glad he replied to someone's!

I would like to know too!
I want to send to Alison Iraheta!

have any of you sent out to your favorite idol contestants?

ive sent to adam lambert in early february. do you think he will reply.

thanks,
-nickj_rocksmysocks