Ive only ever sent to them togther and jared not jensen, but always got a reply.

I have sent to only Jensen and got my picture back signed. This was a few month ago. I think it really just depends when they have time to answer their fanmail. Sometimes you will get a PP and sometimes an authentic.

i also sent an individual request and got nothing. I sent it around a month ago, early march-ish. All the successes that I've seen posted were for both, not just one of them. I think they answered all of the fanmail for both of them and kinda ignored the ones just to one of them, or at least for now. i guess my chances are over since they're done filming? what do you guys think- no chance left? i wish they were still filming :(

hey. the best thing to do is to send requests to both at the same time. sometimes if u give send individual, they give PP. I sent to both of them at the same time and it took a while to get back but it was so worth it! I'm sure you will get something back!

Those of you who have had success from jensen ackles and jared padelecki via the supernatural set did you send indiviual requests or did you send one letter to both jensen and jared. I have tried three times sending individual request with no luck