No, this is legit. We have a Wall of Fame in the back of our classroom. There we put our "successful" tries. Some students in the past have gotten back a few autographs and they are hanging up there.

Hello Everyone! In one of my classes we have an extra credit opportunity. We have to request a celebrity for an autographed picture of themselves, and it'd be even better if they could personalize it by adding our school's name. We have to get the autograph back by the end of the quarter so it count...