My guess would be the signature is real but the dedication might be by the sec as is common with many celebs.

Look at the 'r' in 'For' and in the compliment slip. Most of them look like 'v's.

Either weay I think you have 3 genuine Maggie Smith autographs

Just my thoughts.

Cheers

Hey, I know the cramped signature mentioned so it is hard to say which is genuine. However when Kilmer appeared at Autographica to sign for paying customers a few years ago he was told by the organisers that his abbreviated cramped signature was a bit of a con for paying customers and could he pleas...

I've got Ray and Alan Kennedy. They both witnessed Liverpool winning the European Cup