John McCain AP Success (although opinions needed)

[sex_is_not_the_enemy]

Sent: - 09/09/08
Recv: - 19/01/09

I sent an email (which I believe is now invalid) requesting an autograph. Today I received a 8x10 AP'ed photo, plus a typed and signed letter.

I was wondering if anyone would know if the signature on the letter is authentic? In my opinion, the signature seems a bit too neat for it to be authentic. Plus the top loop in the 'J' seems quite narrower than the other signatures on the board :neutral:

[admin]

Hi Victor

Thank you for your feedback Great Success

You have been added to the list for the $10 gift certificate.

John McCain on Fanmail.biz | Previous Feedback(s) Received

Fanmail

[jasonw]

Hi there ,

The signature on my letter from McCain is a PP, but your's is either:

a) An autopen

OR

b) A preprint of an autopen


Jason

[jasonw]

I have moved the topic to the "Is my autograph authentic" forum for you for futher opinions.

Jason

[sex_is_not_the_enemy]

Cheers for your thoughts, Jason

I'm pretty sure mine is an original (albeit I'm not 110% certain on this) but it really looks like its done by a pen. However, if it were otherwise, I wouldn't be all that suprised...

[jasonw]

http://i433.photobucket.com/albums/qq52 ... G_1782.jpg

You can compare it with this.

[sex_is_not_the_enemy]

http://i433.photobucket.com/albums/qq52 ... G_1782.jpg

You can compare it with this.

Cheers Jason {thumb2}

It's clear that the signatures are different (so that crosses off the chances of it being an AP or PP'ed letter). Now, it's a matter of whether it is actually signed by John himself, or a secretary