Tobey Maguire - In Person - Authentic?

[BatmanForever]

Seller says this autograph was gained in person, which would explain why it's such a basic autograph, opinions? :





Doesn't seem too different from an authentic autograph such as this:

[bud simpson]

Toby has such a simple autograph that it's quite easy to forge. Because of this, unfortunately, I wouldn't trust any 2nd party that's selling one. Looks like to me it's no good.

[woa]

Here are several IP examples. Sorry about the resolution. I am traveling and had to snag these off my website. The high res stuff is on my office machine.

http://img39.imageshack.us/g/59446690.jpg/

Good luck. I don't know if it is real either. It could be easily faked and a photo of Tobey means nothing unless it was a photo of him signing that exact item.

[balladesque]

Looks too simple. You should look for a full signature. I don't trust anyone who sells 'scribbles' so I recommend not to purchase it.