WARNING: Known Scammers & Users To Avoid (With proof!)
Forum rules
Sponsored link: Google Workspace 14-day free trial
Upload your pictures here: Surf My Pictures | Google Photos | Imgbb | Tumblr | Imgur
Sponsored link: Google Workspace 14-day free trial


- carlyscala
- Autograph Collector
- Posts: 252
- Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:25 am
- Contact:
Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
Also I'm not saying no one is doing anything about this seller. The many who have filed disputes and posted this whole topic are being awesome and helpful. THATS what needs to be done and it is being done. Now admin needs to block the IP address. Then all routes will be exhausted I think. I know frustration causes people to just want someone to blame but blame the jerk, not the owner of a site. You don't blame eBay if you get lied to, but toucan dispute via the right avenue and win by doing the right thing and reporting fraud and theft.

At the Deathly Hallows Part II premiere in NYC!
20, huge HP fan, will go to great lengths to see my
favorite cast again and again in person!

Favorite successes: HP trio in person, JK Rowling, all my HP autos in fact, Chuck Palahniuk, Richard Nixon (passed to me from my grandfather), Barack Obama in person, Andy Pettitte, James Franco
TWITTER: @carlyscala
My autograph blog...newly created! Still working on it

Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
Deleting this site wouldn't make a lot of sense.. fixing it would, and wouldn't take much effort. I think that's what's frustrating to so many users here.
Putting it on eBay doesn't offer much protection. eBay would only intervene if a selected online payment system was used to purchase an item, and of those, Paypal is the most (and arguably the only) trustworthy one. And if you're going to use Paypal to pay, they have their own dispute console, so why bother with eBay? With no feedback system and moderation on this forum, all you can really do is research the seller beforehand (search the forum and look through the user's previous sales threads), use Paypal properly and send money as a purchase, demand a Delivery Confirmation number and have the seller post it to the transaction so that Paypal themselves can track it.
Banning an IP address doesn't always work. The user may have a dynamic address, or use a proxy, and banning either of those could result in banning countless other people that may use those same addresses.
Putting it on eBay doesn't offer much protection. eBay would only intervene if a selected online payment system was used to purchase an item, and of those, Paypal is the most (and arguably the only) trustworthy one. And if you're going to use Paypal to pay, they have their own dispute console, so why bother with eBay? With no feedback system and moderation on this forum, all you can really do is research the seller beforehand (search the forum and look through the user's previous sales threads), use Paypal properly and send money as a purchase, demand a Delivery Confirmation number and have the seller post it to the transaction so that Paypal themselves can track it.
Banning an IP address doesn't always work. The user may have a dynamic address, or use a proxy, and banning either of those could result in banning countless other people that may use those same addresses.
- carlyscala
- Autograph Collector
- Posts: 252
- Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:25 am
- Contact:
Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
I agree with you. Other than what has been done by the honest people just wanting to buy, not much else can be done. Fixing it would be great but other than what you said, what else can anyone in charge do? The feedback system exists but i don't know who keeps up with it. I think more moderation is needed and for mods to have more control. What you listed we can do ourselves is what we already should be doing: taking it into our hands and demanding a history and confirmation number.I don't know really much about IP addresses but as far as banning a user i do think that's the best we can really do, honestly. Like you said, you can't ban too much or the honest people will get banned too. Kinda lose-lose, and it'd a flawed system, but it's all we have.

At the Deathly Hallows Part II premiere in NYC!
20, huge HP fan, will go to great lengths to see my
favorite cast again and again in person!

Favorite successes: HP trio in person, JK Rowling, all my HP autos in fact, Chuck Palahniuk, Richard Nixon (passed to me from my grandfather), Barack Obama in person, Andy Pettitte, James Franco
TWITTER: @carlyscala
My autograph blog...newly created! Still working on it

-
- Autograph Collector
- Posts: 1220
- Joined: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:22 am
- Contact:
Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
I am VERY happy to announce I just won the claim on PayPal, and got a full refund! Thank you PayPal!!
Last edited by Blackhawks026 on Tue Oct 11, 2011 5:26 am, edited 1 time in total.
~Currently taking a break from collecting to focus on school~
Harry Potter Autographs: Tom Felton (IP), Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, Alan Rickman, James & Oliver Phelps, Warwick Davis, Matthew Lewis, Shirley Henderson, Maggie Smith, Richard Griffiths, Scarlett Byrne, Robert Hardy, Mirriam Margoyles, Fiona Shaw, Gemma Jones, Hazel Douglas, Imelda Staunten, Harry Melling, Emma Thompson, Zoe Wanamaker, David Ryall, Isabella Laughland, Sophie Thompson, Ciaran Hinds, Julie Walters, Andy Linden, Jim Broadbent, Christian Coulson, Kenneth Branagh, Dave Legeno, Jessica Hynes, Bill Nighy, Jeff Rawle, Amelda Brown, Margery Mason, Natalia Tena, Helen McCrory, Bonnie Wright, John Hurt, Mateylok Gibbs, Chris Rankin, Terence Baylor, Guy Henry, Arben Bajrakturaj, Alfie Enoch, Michelle Fairly, Alexandre Desplat, Ryan Turner, David Bradley, Rhys Ifans and Nina Young
Check out my Harry Potter autographs (along with my entire autograph collection) here : http://tinyurl.com/6uafx5g
Harry Potter Autographs: Tom Felton (IP), Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, Alan Rickman, James & Oliver Phelps, Warwick Davis, Matthew Lewis, Shirley Henderson, Maggie Smith, Richard Griffiths, Scarlett Byrne, Robert Hardy, Mirriam Margoyles, Fiona Shaw, Gemma Jones, Hazel Douglas, Imelda Staunten, Harry Melling, Emma Thompson, Zoe Wanamaker, David Ryall, Isabella Laughland, Sophie Thompson, Ciaran Hinds, Julie Walters, Andy Linden, Jim Broadbent, Christian Coulson, Kenneth Branagh, Dave Legeno, Jessica Hynes, Bill Nighy, Jeff Rawle, Amelda Brown, Margery Mason, Natalia Tena, Helen McCrory, Bonnie Wright, John Hurt, Mateylok Gibbs, Chris Rankin, Terence Baylor, Guy Henry, Arben Bajrakturaj, Alfie Enoch, Michelle Fairly, Alexandre Desplat, Ryan Turner, David Bradley, Rhys Ifans and Nina Young
Check out my Harry Potter autographs (along with my entire autograph collection) here : http://tinyurl.com/6uafx5g
Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
Just got this message from paypel (this is only a part of it)
I'm so going to win this thing too
Like paypal would ever believe that the Tracking Company is named Txt?The seller has responded to our request for tracking information. We
haven't confirmed the tracking information yet but wanted to share the
seller's response with you.
Tracking Company: Txt
Tracking Number: 111111111111
If you have received your item, please cancel your complaint by clicking
the link below:
I'm so going to win this thing too


Ask me a rude question, and you'll get a rude answer, simple as that!
If you want one of my unsigned HQ pictures to print out yourself, just ask
Recent Successes: Matyolok Gibbs, Brahim, Katy Perry, Steffanie Leigh, Cher Lloyd
Favorite TTM Successes: Alexis Bledel, Rachel McAdams, Naya Rivera, Selena Gomez, Michael Muhney, Mary Costa, Alan Rickman, Shirley Henderson, Kathryn Beaumont, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Reed, Jodi Benson, Anne Hathaway, Deborah Ann Woll
Website: Shooting Star
Most Wanted: Lauren Graham, Emma Watson, Tom Felton, Harry Potter Cast, Twilight Cast, Hunger Games Cast
Milestone TTM Autographs: 1. Emma Watson, 10. Amanda Seyfried, 25. Hazel Douglas, 50. Miley Cyrus (PP), 75. Katy Perry
Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
Carly, that's right. It would certainly be nice and helpful to have better protection on this forum in the form of a better feedback system, moderation and banning of trouble users, but ultimately it's still up to us to protect ourselves.
Blackhawk, I'm as glad to hear that you won your case as you are to have won it. Hopefully Gertyke and anyone else Zimmy screwed over will be getting their money back soon as well.
Blackhawk, I'm as glad to hear that you won your case as you are to have won it. Hopefully Gertyke and anyone else Zimmy screwed over will be getting their money back soon as well.
Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
I bought the same autograph card from Zimmy. I have requested a refund from paypal. Thank you for openning this thread 

-
- Autograph Collector
- Posts: 1220
- Joined: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:22 am
- Contact:
Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
Wow, so far you're like the 5th or 6th person that I know of who tried buying that same card off himsfg wrote:I bought the same autograph card from Zimmy. I have requested a refund from paypal. Thank you for openning this thread

Gertyke: Lmao that's great!!! Looks like he know's his little scamming ring is falling apart
~Currently taking a break from collecting to focus on school~
Harry Potter Autographs: Tom Felton (IP), Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, Alan Rickman, James & Oliver Phelps, Warwick Davis, Matthew Lewis, Shirley Henderson, Maggie Smith, Richard Griffiths, Scarlett Byrne, Robert Hardy, Mirriam Margoyles, Fiona Shaw, Gemma Jones, Hazel Douglas, Imelda Staunten, Harry Melling, Emma Thompson, Zoe Wanamaker, David Ryall, Isabella Laughland, Sophie Thompson, Ciaran Hinds, Julie Walters, Andy Linden, Jim Broadbent, Christian Coulson, Kenneth Branagh, Dave Legeno, Jessica Hynes, Bill Nighy, Jeff Rawle, Amelda Brown, Margery Mason, Natalia Tena, Helen McCrory, Bonnie Wright, John Hurt, Mateylok Gibbs, Chris Rankin, Terence Baylor, Guy Henry, Arben Bajrakturaj, Alfie Enoch, Michelle Fairly, Alexandre Desplat, Ryan Turner, David Bradley, Rhys Ifans and Nina Young
Check out my Harry Potter autographs (along with my entire autograph collection) here : http://tinyurl.com/6uafx5g
Harry Potter Autographs: Tom Felton (IP), Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, Alan Rickman, James & Oliver Phelps, Warwick Davis, Matthew Lewis, Shirley Henderson, Maggie Smith, Richard Griffiths, Scarlett Byrne, Robert Hardy, Mirriam Margoyles, Fiona Shaw, Gemma Jones, Hazel Douglas, Imelda Staunten, Harry Melling, Emma Thompson, Zoe Wanamaker, David Ryall, Isabella Laughland, Sophie Thompson, Ciaran Hinds, Julie Walters, Andy Linden, Jim Broadbent, Christian Coulson, Kenneth Branagh, Dave Legeno, Jessica Hynes, Bill Nighy, Jeff Rawle, Amelda Brown, Margery Mason, Natalia Tena, Helen McCrory, Bonnie Wright, John Hurt, Mateylok Gibbs, Chris Rankin, Terence Baylor, Guy Henry, Arben Bajrakturaj, Alfie Enoch, Michelle Fairly, Alexandre Desplat, Ryan Turner, David Bradley, Rhys Ifans and Nina Young
Check out my Harry Potter autographs (along with my entire autograph collection) here : http://tinyurl.com/6uafx5g
- carlyscala
- Autograph Collector
- Posts: 252
- Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:25 am
- Contact:
Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
So glad someone won their claim! Now I think Gertyke is going to win...because there is no way Paypal would ever believe that info they gave you. Glad to see people are seeing results...this is what needs to be done! I doubt Zimmy will be swindling anyone ever again?

At the Deathly Hallows Part II premiere in NYC!
20, huge HP fan, will go to great lengths to see my
favorite cast again and again in person!

Favorite successes: HP trio in person, JK Rowling, all my HP autos in fact, Chuck Palahniuk, Richard Nixon (passed to me from my grandfather), Barack Obama in person, Andy Pettitte, James Franco
TWITTER: @carlyscala
My autograph blog...newly created! Still working on it

-
- Autograph Collector
- Posts: 1779
- Joined: Sun Aug 23, 2009 4:32 pm
- Contact:
Re: WARNING: Do NOT buy from "Zimmy"
Just wondering...Do you think Zimmy has seen this post?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests