Esther Williams success!!!

[motivatedsoup]

I am not convincing myself I know that it is real (that hand writing on my auto was NOT that neat among other things.) and if you don't want to believe it you don't have to but I would appreciate it if all of you would leave this post alone as it is very disrespectful. She JUST died and I am a major Esther fan. You can back off and go jump down someone elses throat. Thank you very much.

[motivatedsoup]

Just heard that Miss Williams died in her sleep yesterday,at the age of 91 you were so lucky to receive this great autograph, which i hope you'll treasure

always. She is one of my all time favorite celebrities ever. I was literally reading her book when I heard the news she passed and I cried for over an hour.

[motivatedsoup]

A wheelchair bound 91 year old with failing eyesight and rheumatoid arthritis (all of which she had) would not have handwriting that was incredibly smooth and flowing, looking like that of a 30 year old. Stop trying to convince yourselves that she signed for you.

P.S. my Grandmother died at age 92, had 3 strokes before she went and could no longer walk, and she still wrote neater then the writing on this auto. So.....not every person that is "old and weak" (how sweet of you at looking at older people that way) writes like they're writing with their teeth.

[luckyas13canbe]

As I have ALWAYS said guys, if you're going to claim fake/real and there is differing opinion, then provide some evidence.

That being said, the argument of it being "disrespectful" because she's just died made me laugh, it hardly makes a difference in a discussion over genuine nature of autographs. Of course this could all be negated if people would stop feeling the need to either post old feedback on the day of a death, or posting on old feedbacks. There's discussion forums for a reason and that's where thoughts on celebs who have died belong.

[Loungeact92]

CONGRATULATIONS!!!

I even love your photo choice, what a great success, I'm jealous! I loved her work also and was sad at her passing, I remember as a child growing up my grandma always watching her films which was how I got exposed to Esther. She will be missed. CONGRATULATIONS again!!

[cjhanson]

CONGRATULATIONS!!!

I even love your photo choice, what a great success, I'm jealous! I loved her work also and was sad at her passing, I remember as a child growing up my grandma always watching her films which was how I got exposed to Esther. She will be missed. CONGRATULATIONS again!!

No need to be jealous over something that is not authentic. Don't worry about it.

[luckyas13canbe]

CONGRATULATIONS!!!

I even love your photo choice, what a great success, I'm jealous! I loved her work also and was sad at her passing, I remember as a child growing up my grandma always watching her films which was how I got exposed to Esther. She will be missed. CONGRATULATIONS again!!

No need to be jealous over something that is not authentic. Don't worry about it.

Getting boring now, if you want to prove your comments, do the forum a favour and provide the evidence. If you don't, then how about you stop posting the same thing over and over again?

[supertoneman]

CONGRATULATIONS!!!

I even love your photo choice, what a great success, I'm jealous! I loved her work also and was sad at her passing, I remember as a child growing up my grandma always watching her films which was how I got exposed to Esther. She will be missed. CONGRATULATIONS again!!

No need to be jealous over something that is not authentic. Don't worry about it.

Getting boring now, if you want to prove your comments, do the forum a favour and provide the evidence. If you don't, then how about you stop posting the same thing over and over again?

i agree with this saying. you have to show proof before you say that it is fake. to the OP congrats on the success.

[parlamentetfanErik]

why don't you guys show us some proof that they're authentic?

[luckyas13canbe]

why don't you guys show us some proof that they're authentic?

Erik, they've displayed their images, if they're fake, then it's easy enough for those who know for sure to post the evidence.. At no point did I say it was/was not real, what I did ask for was evidence to prove the opinions being put forward as without proof will lead to nothing but the same posts over and over again. That is, presuming you can deal with me having an opinion without rushing to badmouth me on other forums.