Johnny Depp success

[dancingirl1]

GREAT photo selection!

[stillluckyas13canbe]

Admittedly your response in this instance and the majority of others have not been necessarily "rude" in the manner delivered. Unfortunately, it's still a rude gesture. True, it is a "feedback" forum as mentioned by someone else, but my interpretation of that is that it's the poster's feedback. If they solicit an opinion, then by all means, provide an opinion. The original poster did not solicit one, and likely knew the authenticity. Perhaps that was not your intention, but it still comes across that way. Perhaps it's just your way of "showing off", either way it's not right.

As indicated, it must be frustrating to new or younger collectors to have what they deem a success immediately ripped apart by a select few that enjoy doing so. It's disgusting.

Precisely Diamond Dave. I also don't think stilluckyas13canbe was particularly rude in tone, but I do think it's not on to go immediately slam down someone's success (and I don't care what any of you say - it is a success - we've all established it's autopen - but you still have to go to the trouble of writing to the agency and sending a photo to at least get an imprint of this autograph).

Had Jackess actually asked "Is this authentic?", then stillluckyas13canbe could've willingly unleashed his showing off of how knowledgeable he is. And you're right Diamond Dave - it is exactly that. As it is, what was said was completely unnecessary, and I suggest perhaps keeping quiet stillluckyas13canbe unless you have something positive or constructive to say. As it is, you've knocked someone down and infuriated the rest of us. We've established that the Johnny Depp autographs are auto-penned, as you so boldly jumped in to say on my Johnny Depp photo too when I posted that. You were the first commenter. - http://www.fanmail.biz/mboard/viewtopic.php?t=308545

Please just re-construct your future comments or don't comment at all...!

Sure, that makes sense. Clearly. Every word.

[MJS73]

and I suggest perhaps keeping quiet...unless you have something positive or constructive to say

Great advice, you should follow it.