I got to admit she wasn't the best. But she wasn't the worst.
But the competiton is now getting very tough.
On the bright side. Here in the UK. Simon Cowells equivilant to Idol is called the X factor. Basically they ditched Idol and didn't put any age limits on the contest.
Not only has the winner done well but the runners up are also doing well.
Check out Shayne Ward (winner), Andy Abraham, Journey South.

Also check out Chico and G4.
So Kelly might get a chnace of being an Idol yet but in her own right.