Is Selena Gomez better than Miley Cyrus?

[Shambler]

Her parents are bad yeah - if they willing to go to these lengths to make some money/get publicity. Her dad's a big wash up from the 90s who needs to get himself back on the map, and he's so tragic that he's using his 15 year old daughter in indecent ways to do that.

[miley cyrus fan]

you know what guys all of you give me a break, their was nothing wrong with the pics, ok their photoshoot pics what the hell is wrong with them, shes 15 years old you can not see her "stuff ,so whats wrong with them, and its not suggestive. man jamie lynn spears is a year older and pregnant give miley a break, alright. and im sure jamie is not going to be lorelai gilmore either.

anyway guys i could go on and on but i dont wanna get my self banned for defending my girl miley lmao. miley rules

[RuleroftheWorld]

you know what guys all of you give me a break, their was nothing wrong with the pics, ok their photoshoot pics what the hell is wrong with them, shes 15 years old you can not see her "stuff ,so whats wrong with them, and its not suggestive. man jamie lynn spears is a year older and pregnant give miley a break, alright. and im sure jamie is not going to be lorelai gilmore either.

anyway guys i could go on and on but i dont wanna get my self banned for defending my girl miley lmao. miley rules

Shes topless. Shes not showing anything, but shes topless. Shes 15. They ARE sexually suggestive photos (thats the only reason they were done, they're hardly an "everyday pose" are they? )

Jamie Lynn is pregnant at 16, thats a completely different situation, you cant even compare the two. One girl is pregnant at 16, the other is posing in covered-topless pics at 15 in a national (global?) magazine.

One is stupid (Jamie Lynn) one is completely sick (Miley).

And dont worry, you wont get banned for defending her (as long as you dont go crazy of course).

I understand you're a big fan of hers, maybe that clouds your judgement. Or maybe its because you're young, you dont actually realise whats wrong with them. I dont know, but what I do know is that those pictures are morally wrong, and thats putting it mildly.

[Shambler]

M.C.Fan, I know you're a bit young but imagine yourself being the father of a 15 year old daughter - would you let her pose for such a suggestive shot, that millions of creepy old men will probably look at/use for disturbing purposes? I certainly wouldn't!


Again, I think that it would be a tasteful shot if she was a different age [like in her twenties or older] - but not a mere child of 15. Things like this are the reason little freaks like junior Spears are having babies when they're barely out of nappies themselves!

[Pencebaseball9]

Miley. I love her accent.