Celebrity Ratings

[TheMailman]

Over-rated: Kiefer is awesome! 24, Lost Boys and Phonebooth made his career. Great actor

Elisha Cuthbert?

[Kirstie]

I think she's under-rated. She's very talented, but I don't think she's been given much of a chance to flaunt it.

Keira Knightley

[TheMailman]

Over-rated: POTC made her, I'm not much of a fan now though, I prefered her in Bend It Like Beckham

Will Smith?

[Aimee OC]

Over-Rated. Although, I Do Like Him. I Love His Songs, Especially 'Switch', & He's Been in So Many Great Movie's. I Especially Thought He Was Great In 'Hitch', 'Men & Black' & 'Bad Boys'!

Dakota Fanning?

[celebrityfan]

Waaaay over-rated!

I couldn't stand her in War of the Worlds because she can't act well, she can scream well. But everyone seems to love her, I don't see it.

Joaquin Phoenix?

[TheMailman]

I think Dakota's an outstanding actress for her age

Joaquin Phoenix: Over-rated, I think 'Walk The Link' made him a different person, but he is an awesome actor

America Ferrera?

[Kirstie]

Hmm...I think she's under-rated. I haven't seen her on Ugly Betty, but apparently, she has some talent!

Thanks for joining us celebrityfan...

Sir Ian McKellan

[TheMailman]

A bit of both really, it's hard to say.

Felicity Huffman

[celebrityfan]

I'm kinda neutral on her. 'Desperate Housewives' was an over-rated show, in my opinion, but in it she wasn't. However, her being nominated for an Oscar this year made her over-rated too.

Gerard Butler?

[Aimee OC]

Haven't Really Seen Much Of His Acting So Can't Really Comment on This One

Bruce Willis?