Autographs For Sale/ Trade forum - Feedback

[cr7]

I like the idea, I think that Jason and Andy's ideas could be used together.

http://www.phpbb.com/community/viewtopi ... 0&t=780735

If a rep system were to be installed however restricted so that only mods could use it it may prevent it being abused as Andy suggested it might. Members could request that moderators for that particular forum update reputation points of another member on the forum (providing details of the transaction if possible)

However.... I agree with Shambler, I don't think admin will care enough to install some sort of system.

While I'm commenting on this section of the forum I'll point out that I feel the rules should be revised... I find them a bit misleading and harsh...

[jasonw]

I like the idea, I think that Jason and Andy's ideas could be used together.

http://www.phpbb.com/community/viewtopi ... 0&t=780735

If a rep system were to be installed however restricted so that only mods could use it it may prevent it being abused as Andy suggested it might. Members could request that moderators for that particular forum update reputation points of another member on the forum (providing details of the transaction if possible)

However.... I agree with Shambler, I don't think admin will care enough to install some sort of system.

While I'm commenting on this section of the forum I'll point out that I feel the rules should be revised... I find them a bit misleading and harsh...

Thanks for your input, I will pm admin to get him to take a look at this thread.
Jason

[jasonw]

Hi,
since there are no other ideas, i think we should just go with the current one. But is Andy banned or something?
Jason

[Trottersfan]

But is Andy banned or something?

Thats what I thought, In the Mod Logs it says he got banned

[jasonw]

Looks like this is not going to happen after all since Andy is banned :neutral:
Jason.

[rittdk01]

I would think that feedback could be found by how long a person has been a member on here. I would like to see a feedback on the buy/sell list as well though. I have only traded on here once a few weeks ago and that worked out well. Anyhow its an idea.

[sgv123]

i think that in order to post in the sell/trade forum you should be a member for a month OR 100 posts.

[sunkissed08]

i thought the idea was great, can't we still do it? another moderator willing to keep track? i would even do it if it would benefit the board and admin likes the idea

[jasonw]

Its Done

[sgv123]

can someone clarify why the suggestion i left will not work?