Fanmail.biz

This Zac Efron/Ashley Tisdale/Vanessa Hudgens success posted by "Miles" is most likely a fake success. He cannot produce the envelope, and he says the success was through an agency that does not represent Zac. Another red flag is that two of the pictures were signed with the same marker, and the obvious "drawn" look to the signatures.

I think this guy should be banned

Hi CDolan02

You are probably right. I will delete his thread in a couple of days.

Fanmail

admin wrote:Hi CDolan02

You are probably right. I will delete his thread in a couple of days.

Fanmail

A couple of thoughts...

1) In previous examples where people have been highly suspicious of members posting fakes, you have said "theres no proof". While I agree with CDolan here, there is actually less "proof" than in previous examples, yet with this one you simply agreed and will remove the thread? I dont understand the difference here? (Not trying to be rude, just cant reword it)

2) Fake success = thread delete, but no ban/warning? Why?

2) Fake success = thread delete, but no ban/warning? Why?

Maybe they deserve a second chance? A PM might be enough to "get them back on track" and not do it again.
I think a ban is a bit harsh, but they should definately have a warning.

As for the Zac Efron "success", its definately a fake. It looks nowhere near anything i've seen from him, neither IPs or TTMs.
It looks like a 5 year old made it :neutral: (no offence to the one who made it)

Hmm..I think banning would be too much. Just tell him nicely or tell him you'll give him a warning next time. Afterall, it's his first time..I think.