Fanmail.biz

1

Well, Cool Success!!!
They Seem Real To Me, But I'm Not An Expert!!!
Congrats Anyway!! {thumb2}

Sprock Chick wrote: They Seem Real To Me, But I'm Not An Expert!!!

Then with all due respect, you shouldnt give an opinion on their authenticity.

I'd give an opinion, but we're banned from offering opinions unless one if asked for

HI Andy316,
I would be very interested to see your opinion...

Oops

Sorry

janiceling wrote:HI Andy316,
I would be very interested to see your opinion...

Assuming these were acquired through the mail, then there are only 2 possible outcomes as results to "successes" from Beckham. The first outcome is that the autograph is stamped, which clearly they aren't, so thats option 1 out the window straight away. Option 2 is that they're secretarial, which in my opinion is what they are. Beckham doesnt sign authentically through the mail, and hasnt done for a few years. The only responses from him in this time have been either stamps or secs. He only signs authentically for one charity, as it seems he chooses to get fully behind one in particular at a time, to "maximise" the potential fund raising.

Well thats my opinion, hope its of some use to you.

1

So those 2 fans met him twice then, correct? Once to pose for phots and then a second time to sign the photos? They must've got really lucky then. Unless David waited for them to print the photos of so he could sign them of course

Question - Where'd you get those pics from anyway?

Do I think the same person signed all 4 pics? Hard to say.

No offence intended here, but about 2-3 times a month, a new member signs up, and with their first post reports a success that are nigh on impossible to get, so dont be surprised if Im not the only one whos sceptical....

If you (or anyone else) believes them to be genuine, then fair enough. I choose to believe otherwise, which is my perogative.

Congrats nonetheless.

Andy316 wrote:So those 2 fans met him twice then, correct? Once to pose for phots and then a second time to sign the photos? They must've got really lucky then. Unless David waited for them to print the photos of so he could sign them of course

Question - Where'd you get those pics from anyway?

Do I think the same person signed all 4 pics? Hard to say.

No offence intended here, but about 2-3 times a month, a new member signs up, and with their first post reports a success that are nigh on impossible to get, so dont be surprised if Im not the only one whos sceptical....

If you (or anyone else) believes them to be genuine, then fair enough. I choose to believe otherwise, which is my perogative.

Congrats nonetheless.

Ok, believe or not, maybe you could go and read the story yourself:

http://www.beckham-magazine.com/forums/ ... hp?t=20242

Maybe you will say those two people are lying....

janiceling wrote: Ok, believe or not, maybe you could go and read the story yourself:

http://www.beckham-magazine.com/forums/ ... hp?t=20242

Maybe you will say those two people are lying....

Ok, now first of all I didnt say they were lying, so DO NOT put words in my mouth :mad: I asked where you got the pics, and I said they must've been LUCKY, which they evidently WERE.

But those two fans make no difference - and had no bearing - on my original statements, and my belief that your success is not authentic.

Like Ive already said, I have my opinion, you have yours, others will have theirs.

Not sure why you're trying to turn this into an argument, you asked for my opinion, I gave it, I said not everyone will agree, and congratulated you on your success, so yeah, why you're trying to start an argument I dont know....