Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

You can also post suggestions, comments to the fanmail.biz database managers here. Do not post your feedback here. Do not request a celebrity address here.
Forum rules
Sponsored link: Browse safely with Opera free VPN! Download now!

Image Search the message board Image
Chris102
Posts: 566
Joined: Sun Oct 09, 2005 7:24 pm
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by Chris102 »

There's a lot of reasons why some celebrities don't sign. Sometimes there are good reasons, like to prevent identity theft, or because their publicist tells them not to sign, and some just don't want to sign! :roll:

I've heard of a lot of celebrities who won't sign blanks (blank paper, index cards, ect) because of identity theft.
Droidboy
Autograph Collector
Autograph Collector
Posts: 14
Joined: Fri Aug 01, 2008 4:27 pm
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by Droidboy »

I try to look at every signature as a gift. If they sign, awesome. If they don't, bummer. But I hate the attitude that these people owe any of us anything. I've seen people post on here that they won't be fans any longer because someone didn't sign something, or people upset because they didn't send back a card or an IRC. It's a risk we all take.

Now that being said, every summer I go to the Indianapolis Colts training camp for a week or so, and there are one or two players who refuse to sign. I'll let the old players get by with it (in my mind), but the young guys who don't take the time to sign and meet the fans kinda grinds my gears. Maybe it's just that I hold them to a different level, but when someone like Peyton Manning will sign everyday, it would go a long way for the fans to have Joe Rookie sign for a bit too.

Gregg
Improvise, Adapt and Overcome!
User avatar
sonofthesouth8
Autograph Collector
Autograph Collector
Posts: 207
Joined: Sun May 25, 2008 2:37 pm
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by sonofthesouth8 »

margotchanning wrote:
autoland wrote:What I always find a little strange is, sometimes big celebs, are much better at signing, then say the winner of X factor, or someone else from reality TV.

Apart from say Leona Lewis, who has made it big, a lot of them are just here for the moment, and then nothing. But because of the POWER of celebrity, we make them overnight stars, it goes to their head, then it's "sorry no autographs" when only last month, they where working in a store.??

But that's the way it goes. :? :?
Yep, I agree with you. Sometimes smaller celebrities are far more up themselves than huge stars! I met a complete nobody at a convention a few weeks ago and she was as rude as hell. They know they're not that famous so they enjoy the power of saying no :lol:
who was it that was mean? if you don't mind me asking.
Image
User avatar
sonofthesouth8
Autograph Collector
Autograph Collector
Posts: 207
Joined: Sun May 25, 2008 2:37 pm
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by sonofthesouth8 »

i hate to speak ill of the dead but Dale Earnhardt Sr. was always kind of a jerk to me... i met him maybe 8 or 9 times and most of the time he wouldn't sign or even acknowledge that you were speaking to him... one time when i was like 11 or 12 i asked him for an autograph and he told me "son they don't pay me to sign autographs"
Image
autoland
Autograph Collector
Autograph Collector
Posts: 393
Joined: Wed Apr 16, 2008 1:42 am
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by autoland »

Chris102 wrote:There's a lot of reasons why some celebrities don't sign. Sometimes there are good reasons, like to prevent identity theft, or because their publicist tells them not to sign, and some just don't want to sign! :roll:

I've heard of a lot of celebrities who won't sign blanks (blank paper, index cards, ect) because of identity theft.

That's a great point, about Identity theft. But a lot of stars, do use a few ways of signing, which they then modify, if you ask for an autograph, to save themselves.

And a lot of celebs, will give you an autograph, that's unreadable.
Chris102
Posts: 566
Joined: Sun Oct 09, 2005 7:24 pm
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by Chris102 »

Droidboy wrote:I try to look at every signature as a gift. If they sign, awesome. If they don't, bummer. But I hate the attitude that these people owe any of us anything. I've seen people post on here that they won't be fans any longer because someone didn't sign something, or people upset because they didn't send back a card or an IRC. It's a risk we all take.

Now that being said, every summer I go to the Indianapolis Colts training camp for a week or so, and there are one or two players who refuse to sign. I'll let the old players get by with it (in my mind), but the young guys who don't take the time to sign and meet the fans kinda grinds my gears. Maybe it's just that I hold them to a different level, but when someone like Peyton Manning will sign everyday, it would go a long way for the fans to have Joe Rookie sign for a bit too.

Gregg
I don't want to start an arguement, but techniquely, most celebrities do owe us something, because we're the fans paying to buy their albums and movies and books - without fans, these celebrities today would be just like you and me. We are giving our hard-earned money away to these people, and they can't take a few seconds out of their day to write on something as a thank-you? The problem is that most big stars let their fame change them and make them different people than they were before they were famous.
Droidboy
Autograph Collector
Autograph Collector
Posts: 14
Joined: Fri Aug 01, 2008 4:27 pm
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by Droidboy »

Chris102 wrote:
Droidboy wrote:I try to look at every signature as a gift. If they sign, awesome. If they don't, bummer. But I hate the attitude that these people owe any of us anything. I've seen people post on here that they won't be fans any longer because someone didn't sign something, or people upset because they didn't send back a card or an IRC. It's a risk we all take.

Now that being said, every summer I go to the Indianapolis Colts training camp for a week or so, and there are one or two players who refuse to sign. I'll let the old players get by with it (in my mind), but the young guys who don't take the time to sign and meet the fans kinda grinds my gears. Maybe it's just that I hold them to a different level, but when someone like Peyton Manning will sign everyday, it would go a long way for the fans to have Joe Rookie sign for a bit too.

Gregg
I don't want to start an arguement, but techniquely, most celebrities do owe us something, because we're the fans paying to buy their albums and movies and books - without fans, these celebrities today would be just like you and me. We are giving our hard-earned money away to these people, and they can't take a few seconds out of their day to write on something as a thank-you? The problem is that most big stars let their fame change them and make them different people than they were before they were famous.
Improvise, Adapt and Overcome!
autoland
Autograph Collector
Autograph Collector
Posts: 393
Joined: Wed Apr 16, 2008 1:42 am
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by autoland »

It's pretty fair to say, that some celebs will never sign, indeed Kevin Spacey once told a group of people, that it is not in his contract to sign autographs, so most times he dont.

When his in an occassional good mood, (once in a blue moon) he does sign. But we should never get so desperate, to get an autograph from any celeb, that we make an embarrassment of ourselves.

I personally do not ask, celebs for their autograph, in the streets, the most I give them is a very respectful "Hello" sometimes I wish, that I could do it, as I know that if they say "yes" then I've a real authentic autograph.
User avatar
indigo15
Autograph Collector
Autograph Collector
Posts: 182
Joined: Mon Jan 15, 2007 11:01 pm
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by indigo15 »

:) I agree that most celebrities owe their fame and status to the fans. Sports stars are a little different because they got to where they are based on their talent, not based on how much people like them. Still, I think sports stars should still do what they can for their supporters...

But back to reality stars not wanting to sign autographs...I heard some really nasty things about Taylor Hicks ("American Idol" season 5 winner) a few weeks ago. I'd heard that he had gotten a really big head and didn't want to sign autographs, and according to some people, he got like that while he was still on "Idol!" Doesn't sound like someone who's deserving of the title "American Idol" to me...

But even bigger stars, like Cameron Diaz for example...on numerous occasions I have seen her / heard of her blowing fans off, saying "Sorry, I'm not signing anything today."

I wish all celebrities (no matter if they're A-list or D-List) were more like people like Tom Cruise or Will Smith--they're always nice to their fans, they always sign as many autographs in person as they can. They're two of the biggest stars in the world, and they always come through for their fans.
TTM SUCCESS: Kris Allen, David Archuleta, Aaron Ashmore, Shawn Ashmore, Mike Barz, Lance Bass (x2), Coby Bell (x2), Kameron Bink, Eric Carroll, Austin Carty, Eddie Cibrian, Misha Collins, Nicholas D'Agosto (x2), Tim Daly, Chris Daughtry, Melinda Doolittle (x2), Michael Emerson (x2), Chris Evans, Joey Fatone, Drew Fuller, Matt Giraud, Danny Gokey (x2), Greg Grunberg, Bret Harrison (x2), Melissa Joan Hart, Chelsie Hightower, Sam Huntington, Yvonne Jung, Bruce Kanegai (x3), Daniel Dae Kim, Yunjin Kim, Kristin Kreuk, Ken Leung, Patrick Levis, Blake Lewis, Jason Lezak, Gev Manoukian, Curt Mega, Jonathan Murphy, Masi Oka, Hayden Panettiere, Scarlett Pomers, Chris Richardson, Mark Salling, Ryne Sanborn, Drew Seeley, Sabrina Sloan, Jordin Sparks, Christy Smith (x2), Phil Stacey, Channing Tatum, Tia Texada, TJ Thyne, Mark Wahlberg, Brooke White (x2), Jason Wiles, Kris Williams

Latest IP: Emilio Dosal [10-18-2014 at SYTYCD Tour]
User avatar
margotchanning
Autograph Collector
Autograph Collector
Posts: 1572
Joined: Tue Jul 24, 2007 10:38 pm
Contact:

Re: Sorry I can't give you an autograph?

Unread post by margotchanning »

indigo15 wrote::) I agree that most celebrities owe their fame and status to the fans. Sports stars are a little different because they got to where they are based on their talent, not based on how much people like them. Still, I think sports stars should still do what they can for their supporters...

But back to reality stars not wanting to sign autographs...I heard some really nasty things about Taylor Hicks ("American Idol" season 5 winner) a few weeks ago. I'd heard that he had gotten a really big head and didn't want to sign autographs, and according to some people, he got like that while he was still on "Idol!" Doesn't sound like someone who's deserving of the title "American Idol" to me...

But even bigger stars, like Cameron Diaz for example...on numerous occasions I have seen her / heard of her blowing fans off, saying "Sorry, I'm not signing anything today."

I wish all celebrities (no matter if they're A-list or D-List) were more like people like Tom Cruise or Will Smith--they're always nice to their fans, they always sign as many autographs in person as they can. They're two of the biggest stars in the world, and they always come through for their fans.
I agree with everything you said {thumb2} It annoys me more when celebrities are rude ip (it actually annoys me when anybody is rude to me for no reason :lol: ) If they don't reply to my letter, I don't really mind. I can understand them not wanting to trawl through piles of fanmail but there's no excuse for being rude to people who queue for hours to see you and support you.
Image

http://www.freewebs.com/caribbean-queen My Autograph Collection

http://www.youtube.com/imalittlemidget - Check out my singing on youtube!


Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 19 guests