Just a suggestion to the mods and managers about emails

[smith_and_pyle]

Ok... I know the rules on "email successes" on this forum. And I can say with a lot of other people, it really ticks me off when someone posts a success then puts under the photo "private email sorry" is there anything we can do about this, like not let these successes be posted or something, because isn't this forum a "celebrity address sharing forum" I just don't think its right to post a success then "sorry private email" lets do something about this.

[twilightlover0607]

I have looked for hours for email addresses before with no luck. It's part of the hobby. If someone is a big enough fan they should try to find an email address themself. Also emails can't spammed quickly if they get out and then the person stops replying. So, that's just my opinion on this topic.

[smith_and_pyle]

No, and I completely understand that, I've even spent DAYS looking for a certain email, I've had luck sometimes, then sometimes I haven't had luck, but what I'm saying is, this is an address SHARING forum, not a "private email, sorry" forum. And if you do ask the person that has had the success their completely rude and mean about it, automatically saying that you're going to spam it. I dunno, this is my opinion....

[ScottishDan]

A private/email address can be spammed very quickly and people just use it as an excuse to get a "free autograph". In an ideal world we should be able to share addresses but it is just too dangerous and we must respect the celebrity. For example Rory McIlroy's email address was very quickly spammed and as a result they stopped giving out signed photos and true fans missed out. I remember speaking to the agent and she was not happy with this website for giving it out and I felt quite sorry for her.

[kimmylee]

I think what OP is trying to say is that they understand that, but why do members insisit on posting the success when they are not willing to share the address.

It is rude and talk about rubbing peoples nose's in it! "Look what I got! But I am not going to share on the feedback test an address forum haha"!

It would be better that they didn't post on Feedback (which after all is reporting a succss/failure at such and such an address), but put it somewhere like Autograph Diaries where it isn't so prominent.

[ScottishDan]

This website isn't all just about addresses all the time. It's an autograph collecting forum and if people wish to share anything autograph related whether that includes an address or not then that should be ok. I would rather see a post about someone sharing an autograph they obtained without an address other than no post at all. I don't think the majority of people are being rude, just being sensible. Just my opinion.

[twilightlover0607]

This website isn't all just about addresses all the time. It's an autograph collecting forum and if people wish to share anything autograph related whether that includes an address or not then that should be ok. I would rather see a post about someone sharing an autograph they obtained without an address other than no post at all. I don't think the majority of people are being rude, just being sensible. Just my opinion.

I agree with you! Someone should be happy about their success and want to share it! If they don't want to give the address/ email out then it's their choice. People who are rude I don't like. They could say no in a nice way! If someone found a new address for someone like Robert Pattinson then, it's unlikey that the person would post the address and I respect that!

[nickmoore777]

Although they don't give you the address, they do give you the knowledge that if you do spend hours for the address you are not completely wasting your time. Their posts tell us that the person does reply through email, so it is worth looking for it. Would you rather not have the post, and not knowing whether it's a waste of time looking for the email or not.

Personally I don't use emails, but my opinion on the matter is above.

[RYAN-J]

Although they don't give you the address, they do give you the knowledge that if you do spend hours for the address you are not completely wasting your time. Their posts tell us that the person does reply through email, so it is worth looking for it. Would you rather not have the post, and not knowing whether it's a waste of time looking for the email or not.

Personally I don't use emails, but my opinion on the matter is above.

BINGO! That's how I look at it too. I don't see why people get so upset when they don't post them. I don't whine and complain about it, but rather start doing my own searching for it. & I rarely ever ask them to confirm it either, if I think its the one, I send an email off. if it comes back as 'failure' then I start looking again.

RYAN-J

[smith_and_pyle]

I think what OP is trying to say is that they understand that, but why do members insisit on posting the success when they are not willing to share the address.

It is rude and talk about rubbing peoples nose's in it! "Look what I got! But I am not going to share on the feedback test an address forum haha"!

It would be better that they didn't post on Feedback (which after all is reporting a succss/failure at such and such an address), but put it somewhere like Autograph Diaries where it isn't so prominent.

Thank you, thats exactly what I was trying to say.