Opinions on this Bob Dylan autograph?

[Jack.S]

Does anyone know or could tell me if they think this is genuine or not?



Thank you

[Jack.S]

The listing ends in an hour, can anyone help me out please? I'm DESPERATE!

[johnnylightninglives]

I have no idea but my dad used to listen to his music but personally i always thought he had a horrible voice and his music is horrible...

[Jack.S]

He has written and recorded some of the greatest music I have ever heard and I love his voice, especially now he is older it just sounds amazing!

[parlamentetfanErik]

is it signed upside down?

[Jack.S]

It is indeed. I didn't win it though I was out bid at literally the last second. Any thoughts?

Also, what about this one?

[parlamentetfanErik]

the 2nd one looks better than the first one

[Jack.S]

I asked the seller of the second one how he got it and he told me he is a limo driver who drove a journalist (David Castell) around when he came to the Isle of Wight (the autograph is also being sold with poster tickets from isle of Wight festival) and this journalist met Bonn and got a signed photo which he gave to the limo driver as he was into Dylan. I think he's telling the truth as he's gone into a lot of detail. Here is exactly what he told me:

"hello im a limo driver service an i used to drive the journelist around when he spent times on isle of wight his name was david castell an at that point he saw bob dylan at the festival an after festival he went on set of hearts of fire where pic an sign where done as for me getting it as a gift as im in to bob dylan"

What do you think?

[parlamentetfanErik]

Well if i were you I wouldn't buy anything especially not from Ebay. TONS of stuff are fake and it's Bob Dylan were talking about. the seller seems to have a trustworthy story about this so it seems safe but as I said I wouldn't buy it.

[Jack.S]

But the writing, especially on the 'B', match with Dylan's handwriting.