Did anyone read their privacy policy? This part bothers me:
Information submitted at the time of registration or submission may be used for marketing and promotional purposes by celebritymerch.com Productions and may be shared with companies that have been pre-screened by celebritymerch.com Productions.
So, I admit that I haven't tried them.

I guess I just trust SFM more. I use a unique email address when I ask for pictures from them, as I've done for YEARS, and have never received another email to that address ('cept of course the autoreply right when I send the request.) Plus look how many A-list stars SFM has. It's like the industry trusts them too. I was looking at Nissaea's post http://www.fanmail.biz/mboard/viewtopic.php?t=23916 and that's just a huge bunch of really nice pics from a lot of really big stars.
Sorry, I guess this is really just a rant. Maybe someone can tell me more about Celebrity Merch.