Carly Smithson, I can't believe it!!

[Melindabear2002]

And Taylor Hicks wasn't that good looking. And the year with Jennifer Hudson, did the people voting just lose their minds? No way Jasmine and Diana were better than her or some of the others that got booted.

[guilder1st]

IMO Carly and David Cook are the best singers this season. They both have amazing voices and will probably go on to have amazing careers. Carly definitely didn't deserve to go home tonight.

[Melindabear2002]

No but she'll be fine. Maybe she'll be like Chris and it'll work out better for her. Sometimes I think it does.

[glucklich]

No but she'll be fine. Maybe she'll be like Chris and it'll work out better for her. Sometimes I think it does.

I sure hope so. If she comes out with anything, I'm definitely going to buy it.

[Melindabear2002]

Me to. She's got an amazing voice.

[scouser#1]

I was actually listening to that ugly one (David Archuleta ) yesterday( what girls see in him i don't know), and i was laughing to myself because he has absolutely NO talent. I honestly hate talent shows like american idol, x factor britains got talent...... because i really don't want to watch a bunch of wannabes on TV looking for attention

[sydneyown]

wow i could not agree more with this post. i seriously wanted Jason to go home (even though i love the bloke to death and wanted to have a chance to talk to him and keep him all to myself). Carly has an enormous amount of potential (no worries she'll have a new recording contract and will make millions) and seriously it's time to get Syesha booted off too, she's ruthless like archuleta.

[glucklich]

So I was just watching "American Idol Extra" since Carly was on it.

Michael Johns came out and they were talking about being voted off. The interviewer goes "Do you think it matters now how well you do each night? Or do you think that there's that fan base that will constantly vote for you?" And Michael Johns and Carly both agreed that there was a fan base that will vote for you no matter what. To which Carly added "I think it's especially hard on the girls this season, because the guys have these girls voting for them, and it's hard because I don't think that there are as many guys who vote as girls....like cute little Archuleta, come on". lol so that just goes to show that they even think that there are all these girls that vote for this guys regardless on how well they do.

Geez, I miss Carly....

[Melindabear2002]

I actually disagree with that. Most of the seasons the guys have a harder time than the girls, even with the judges. They just tend to not make it very far. And they've had guys that are much better looking. To be honest everyone is more talented this year. And when you get later on the guys that are left and really talented. When it's like 2 guys and all girls people don't go saying "they're only voting for the girls because they're hot".

[glucklich]

Now Brooke is gone too!!! What. The. Heck?! Seriously!! So back to back Carly then Brooke...I'm honestly not watching the rest of this season. I can't stand anyone that's left on the awful show....the two most deserving got voted out back to back and I'm annoyed.....Whatever. If either of them come out with anything I'm totally buying it because this is ridiculous.