ROB PATTINSON SUCCESSES

[cdunn]

Sorry, it's definitely secretarial.

But congrats anyway! Still a fine success {thumb2}

[M:chael]

Sorry, it's definitely secretarial.

But congrats anyway! Still a fine success {thumb2}

Hi I'd love to see your proof. Like your comparisons, etc.

You have none right?

[cdunn]

Except for the fact that I met him in Canada two weeks ago.

There's no way he can fulfill requests from the U.K. AND L.A. addresses with random USA postmarks from Seattle. (Mind you, he's filming in Western Cananda, not Eastern - if it was Eastern I would concede the possibility of the Seattle postmark.)

Also, many "successes" have stated the return address was filled out by Robert as well. If that would be the case, that would mean it was signed and the envelope stuffed at least FAIRLY close to the recieved date. How could he ship it from the U.K. if he's in Cananda?

And why would he fill in return addresses? Would it not make more sense that a secretary and is bothing signing and stuffing the envelopes?

You want my physical proof? First off, let me note that this post does not show a picture...

Keep in mind: it should not be my job to proove it to be a fraud, you should be able to prove its authenticity. So, that being said, find me ONE (just one - trust me, I've looked and have found none) pre-printed Robert Pattinson autograph OR any autograph with a Certificate of Authenticity (not a COA from an individual or a private "company") from a reputable third party authentication company (like PSA or JSA) that matches any TTM success.

Now... I will patiently wait for your rebuttal.

[M:chael]

Okay, first off your right no picture...you should be an autograph expert since you knew something was secretarial without seeing it!

I don't need to prove it as Yellow has already done so in the best way possible. I believe she has given you the link at least 4 times.
http://www.fanmail.biz/mboard/viewtopic ... 6&t=104897

In that topic that she made there are pictures of him signing autographs and pictures of him next to / with autographs (which must be authentic, since I don't suppose a secretary signed it than made Rob take a picture with it). Well, that is way better than an autograph authenticated by a third party... whatever. Also, there is an autograph from an IP success.

PSA has said AP/PP are authentic, so not really the best (thats just says how in dept they are) - I'd rather compare autographs to autographs from autographworld. But anyways the closest to a PP would be this.
(it's in Yellow's in dept topic, but you obviously didn't look at it.)

About the whole envelope thing- Some celebs choose to address envelopes - I don't know why, if you want I can make a list of celebs who do. Other celebs draw doodles on envelopes or answer a question on them, again I don't why. But you can not use the argument that Rob is just too famous to do so like other celebs (not saying you did, just speculating you will).

About the whole where it is sent - Someone talked to his agency and they said they forward his fan mail to his current location.

[lizane]

YOU CAN'T BE SERIOUS, cdunn!! :mad: Either you're blind, can't read or don't know anything about Robert Pattinson or autographs at all! Your reasons for an autograph to be "secretarial" is the most pathetic one yet. I have never come across such nonsense!

How many times do I have to tell you that it's all authentic, and that I've proven it much better than you could ever prove it's so-called "secretarial".

You clearly have never heard that mail gets forwarded to a destination, as Rob's agent said.

And for the last time, as Michael said, check the very detailed thread I made about his TTM autographs! It had preprints, in person photos and the very first success reported here back in 2006, as well as a filled out questionnaire.

Now STOP posting nonsense, this is your last warning.

[jasonw3]

Michael and Lizanne,

Just ignore cdunn. He's trying to spread baloney to gain attention.