RTS's being counted as Successes on Feedback Pages

[mufcdd]

yes, your point is good, but rts's are always correct, and no success is mistaken as a rts, just the other way around... see?

That sentence doesnt even make sense.

No one counts an RTS as a success, but its FEEDBACK, right? And therefore it needs to stay so that people can see if the address is good or not.

I dont understand your point in this thread to be honest.

[Johnny's Fan]

I'm not sure if the original poster meant sometimes when you click on a feedback marked as a success, you actually find on the first post it was an RTS. I have found that a few times, and it is very annoying.

Like most people, I am happy to find looking at a celeb if there have been any RTS's amongst the successes, but when I click on one labelled a success, and it isn't, it's irritating.

[mufcdd]

I'm not sure if the original poster meant sometimes when you click on a feedback marked as a success, you actually find on the first post it was an RTS. I have found that a few times, and it is very annoying.

Like most people, I am happy to find looking at a celeb if there have been any RTS's amongst the successes, but when I click on one labelled a success, and it isn't, it's irritating.

Yeah if someone says "success" on their thread title and its an RTS then I agree, its annoying.

But I dont see where else that RTS are labelled as "success", if someone can point me in the right direction I'd appreciate it, as it seems like we're discussing something that doesnt exist?

[Johnny's Fan]

No, I'm pretty sure I've seen posts clearly marked as an RTS, but someone has accidentally logged it as a success. Like someone pressed the wrong button or something.

I will have to see if I can find some to show you. I can't honestly say I have found hundreds, but enough to make me feel annoyed.

[mufcdd]

No, I'm pretty sure I've seen posts clearly marked as an RTS, but someone has accidentally logged it as a success. Like someone pressed the wrong button or something.

I will have to see if I can find some to show you. I can't honestly say I have found hundreds, but enough to make me feel annoyed.

Do you mean when a Mod/admin replies saying "Congrats on your success"?

If so, thats an "automatic" reply so to speak, and is easily made an error.

But its not "logged" any different to the real successes. In fact, those replies from the Moderating team actually do NOTHING by way of logging stuff, its all automatically logged from the moment a thread is posted.

[Johnny's Fan]

You know when you get to this page of a celebrities profile:

http://www.fanmail.biz/feedback/Aaron_Eckhart.html

And all the sucesses are listed along with any RTS?

Sometimes when the tester results say they are a "success" you click on the link expecting to find a success, and you clearly see the topic labelled as an "RTS" but someone, a Mod whoever, has actually marked it as a success in the tester result. So amongst all the results you have a RTS but it's wrongly marked as a success.

[mufcdd]

You know when you get to this page of a celebrities profile:

http://www.fanmail.biz/feedback/Aaron_Eckhart.html

And all the sucesses are listed along with any RTS?

Sometimes when the tester results say they are a "success" you click on the link expecting to find a success, and you clearly see the topic labelled as an "RTS" but someone, a Mod whoever, has actually marked it as a success in the tester result. So amongst all the results you have a RTS but it's wrongly marked as a success.

Ahhhhh I finally get what you mean now!!

In that case, its down to laziness on the Mods part lol.

[khackdrums]

If member's would take the time to look at a celebrities past feedback, they would notice RTS's are clearly labeled in red letters. They are clearly distinguishable from successes which are labeled in green... It's the members responsibily to do their own research.

Khackdrums

[jdp3577]

You know when you get to this page of a celebrities profile:

http://www.fanmail.biz/feedback/Aaron_Eckhart.html

And all the sucesses are listed along with any RTS?

Sometimes when the tester results say they are a "success" you click on the link expecting to find a success, and you clearly see the topic labelled as an "RTS" but someone, a Mod whoever, has actually marked it as a success in the tester result. So amongst all the results you have a RTS but it's wrongly marked as a success.

if you read the top of the page you posted a link to it says Feedback received for Aaron Eckhart:
it doesnt say successes

[Johnny's Fan]

To be honest I'm sorry I mentioned this.

When you look at all the feedback RESULTS for a celebrity, you will find green for a success and red for RTS right?

Sometimes when you click on a green success (which I take it I cam correct in assuming, this should mean "this address works"), in actual fact it should have been labelled a big massive "this address does not work RTS".

So someone along the way has got it wrong.

I'm not saying it's a big problem, but I just thought I would throw my 2 cents in and mention it.

I do understand how the forum works, and I do a lot of research, which is how along my travels I have found a few wrongly labelled "successes".