Is there anybody on here who is actually happy about success

[musicfan]

i dont like it when someone says the authenticy of the autograph without the user even asking! every john travolta/clint eastwood. some bone head likes to yell out ITS A SEC ( )

Your one of the worst!!!!!!!!!! You are one of the members constantly shooting off about authenticity without knowing what you are talking about. I'm honestly shocked you even made that comment considering you are so guilty of doing it.

Could not agree more, it is also my opinion that you are one of the worst if not the worst offender.
That being said, I do feel if a comment is done with respect and to educate the poster and other members that might waste there time and money because they think they will get the real deal, I dont see anything wrong with commenting.
1) This is an autograph site and the definition of an autograph is a signiture handwritten by its author
2) There are no rules against posting comments on authentisity (although it should be done respectfully and from people that know what they are talking about)

in reguards to your #2 statement:

but if the poster says "no comments on MY autograph authenticity" there should be no comments about it.....period. because its very disrespectful when someone says "..no comments" and then someone says "..its fake.." some people dont need to be educated about it...and some people just dont wanna know...they wanna collect and thats it.

[chriscollector]

Ryco11757 you should of told him what you had to say...there is a nice way to say things...dont be like chriscollector...he has been known to say things like that too...just so you know....and by the way there are waaaay many other people who say things more than you do Ryco11757 have a great night

Like what? Saying what is true?? How or why should anyone be nice when a pot is calling the kettle black. To openly condemn "others" who are persistantly rude or carying on as if they are authenticators, when you are one of the worst; how am I rude?

Musicfan, you and he are a match made in heaven. Both completely oblivious to your own negative attributes.

I call it like I see it, and nothing hurts more than the truth.

[Nicksportsautographs]

It isn't actually a success if it's secretarial, autopen, pre-print, etc. If people don't like the truth, then either don't write to these celebs, like Travolta, or don't post about it.

And, it has nothing to do with respect. If someone posts saying "No comments about authenticity" then they are just begging for someone to post about it. Seriously, get over it. You got back a fake autograph, there are no two ways about it.

[musicfan]

Ryco11757 you should of told him what you had to say...there is a nice way to say things...dont be like chriscollector...he has been known to say things like that too...just so you know....and by the way there are waaaay many other people who say things more than you do Ryco11757 have a great night

Like what? Saying what is true?? How or why should anyone be nice when a pot is calling the kettle black. To openly condemn "others" who are persistantly rude or carying on as if they are authenticators, when you are one of the worst; how am I rude?

Musicfan, you and he are a match made in heaven. Both completely oblivious to your own negative attributes.

I call it like I see it, and nothing hurts more than the truth.

you can say what you want... ;) i was horrible when i started on here (And i admit that...lol) but now im nothing like that....so you can say what you please... and trust me you have your days to rude. but anywhoo your words dont hurt me...i know how i was before DEC. 25 ( when i decided to turn around my attitude) but now i've been good. yup and i call it like i see it too....the truth does hurt...and thats why you got defensive!

[chriscollector]

Hey Ryyco here's JUST from your last 15 posts. And you hate how people make claims about authenticity? And the best part this tiny list each comment is for a different celeb. So, I'm either rude or very good at comprehensive reading......hmmmmmmmm. What ever could the answer be??

this is a known AP. i have his AP autograph also witha black and white pic.

hey! its a AP not PP but congrats! nice photos!

Looks very simliar to her TTM successes.... what does everyone else think? Is this authentic or secretarial? I was told all her fanmail gets passed on to her secretary... but seeing how this is a VV success I'm really excited that maybe mine are real too?!

i would say sec because her IP signature is much more messy. and this one you can she her full name. BTW TTM is also a sec with S.J.P

most times it is a PP or AP. never a sec.

D-E-N-I-A-L!!!! its a AP. get over it. a monkey get spot that

its AP

i think it is a PP. i have the same photo

[musicfan]

It isn't actually a success if it's secretarial, autopen, pre-print, etc. If people don't like the truth, then either don't write to these celebs, like Travolta, or don't post about it.

And, it has nothing to do with respect. If someone posts saying "No comments about authenticity" then they are just begging for someone to post about it. Seriously, get over it. You got back a fake autograph, there are no two ways about it.

it is a matter of respect because if someone saying not to comment on the signed photo's authenticity and its not showing respect of the poster's wishes..its not that people dont wanna hear the truth about it being fake....if its a sec. then a huge arugment starts then it gets locked by a mond because someone starts a fight...when in the beggining when the poster said no comments about it...it wasnt respected.

[TwiHardPotterFan]

i agree some people are really rude and there is no reason to bring anyone down. if i have ever offended anyone i am sorry i am not trying to be a hypocrite and claim i'm perfect but sometimes people need to be nicer and sometimes keep their comments to themselves.

[omgitscaro]

IMO--- I do wish some of the rudeness would go away though, just because someone is trying to help doesn't mean you have to be all like "um, I didn't ask. " they're just trying to help. Why would you want to live your life keeping something that's not even authentic? Just my opinion.

Yes, but their "help" is not wanted- therefore it is not being helpful, it is being rude. Plus, half the time their intent is not to help at all, it is simply to annoy or demoralise.

True, I didn't really think of that when I first posted. :neutral:

I do think it should still be pointed out if the person thinks it's authentic though.

Then again, I don't want the person to get their hopes down on collecting and simply give up -- thinking "does ANYONE sign authentically TTM?!" so yeah.

I think this is a good discussion. Lots of good opinions.

[jjjj]

I always picture some 10 year old coming on here and saying "hey check out my Travolta autograph" and some pissed off loser 40 year old feeling like a big man tellin the kid its a fake LOL

The truth is some people prefer ignorance and dont care either way if the sig is real and well that is ok with me. Though these same people will complain later on when they go to trade off the sig but to each their own.

[musicfan]

I always picture some 10 year old coming on here and saying "hey check out my Travolta autograph" and some **** off loser 40 year old feeling like a big man tellin the kid its a fake LOL

The truth is some people prefer ignorance and dont care either way if the sig is real and well that is ok with me. Though these same people will complain later on when they go to trade off the sig but to each their own.

but 99% of the time no one ever asks if they are real (EPS. young kid)they dont wanna know, so why do ppl on this site care that muchabout that...and thats the funy thing...they know they are young so why do you say "its fake " they didnt ask them...why cant people just say congrats and move on...?