Is this real?

[Carmelo15]

As you can see from my avatar I am a HUGE fan of Emily Osment and I saw a chance to finally get her autograph.

But I am just wondering are these real autographs?

I would like to ask people who have her autograph to help me.

Thanks for the help

Here are the images:



Thanks,
Carmelo

[James]

Well, the two signatures you've posted are different from each other, so that is a worrying start...

I can't really help as I am not a expert on her autograph, but they do look fishy to be as they are different looking signatures.

Where did you see these autographs?

James

[Carmelo15]

umm in an ebay auction

the first one claims to be in-person in an event in Florida April 2007 while the second one is a re-print

I posted both of them since the second one is way cheaper

EDIT: I checked on one of the fansites and it says Emily was in Florida to do the Disney Channel Games in Florida in Apr 24-27...so there might be a chance that the seller wasn't lying...however I just need somebody who have her autograph to help me confirm

[James]

I suppose it could be real.. or the seller is prepared and has noticed where she was... it is hard to tell.

The second is probably a PP then

[Carmelo15]

Well I am happy for a PP since its so hard to get her autograph and I can't afford the "authentic" one...

[dgangel]

Comparing them to Emiley's in person success, I would say that neither of them are authentic.



http://www.fanmail.biz/mboard/viewtopic.php?t=58726